Translation Notes:
Epistularum Q. Horatii Flacci
Liber Primus

Epistula XII

2. si recte, etc.: there are two reasons given why Iccius should not complain. First, if he knows how to enjoy the material advantages of his position, living well and keeping good health, riches could give him no more. Second, if, on the other hand, he lives simply and frugally though abundance is accessible to him, he would desire no more evne in the midst of wealth, in which case a fortune would do him no good.
7. in medio positorum, what is ready at hand, i.e. the abundance of Agrippa's house.
8. urtica, cf. Plin. H. N. XXI.15.93. ut: concessive.
10. vel quia, etc.: i.e. your nature is such that money wouldn't spoil it, and besides, your philosophical studies have given you true views of virtue and all other goods.
12. miramur, etc.: an indirect proof of the philosophical enthusiasm of Iccius, and so still more indirectly of the truth of v. 11. Democriti: the great atomist of Abdera, the Laughing Philosopher, of whom the story was told alluded to in v. 12. Cf. Democritus ut quam minime animus a cogitationibus abduceretur patrimonium neglexit, agros deseruit incultos, Cic. de Fin. V.29.87.
14. inter scabiem, etc.: i.e. the times of Democritus were less worldly than our own, and hence it is a stronger proof of devotion to philosophy when you study such themes amid the present race for wealth than when Democritus did so.
15. nil parvum, etc., study no petty wisdom, i.e. are not drawn away from lofty themes to the petty interests of the day. sublimia, celestial themes (tà metéora), i.e. the study of the heavens, pure science, the questions enumerated below.
16. mare compescant: i.e. control the waves.
17. iussaene: whether there is any law in their movement as natural bodies, or whether they are directed by mechanical forces, untrammelled by law.
18. obscurum: a kind of predicate adjective belonging only with premat.
19. quid velit: i.e. what it means, or aims at. possit: i.e. what are the limits of its power, as the question is spoken of in Lucretius, quid fieri possit et quid non, particularly, no doubt, in reference to the influence of celestial phenomena on human affairs. concordia discors, the dissentient harmony, i.e. various in manifestation, but joined in a common plan; cf. v. 20.
20. Empedocles (444 B.C.): the first great natural philosopher who referred all things to natural causes, excluding intelligence from any share in natural events. Stertinium: taken jocosely as a type of the Stoic philosopher, who assigned an intelligent will (lógos) to the universe. Cf. Sat. II.3.33. acumen: cf. virtus Scipiadae, Sat. II.1.72.
21. verum seu, etc.: returning to the idea in vv. 5-8. piscis: as a type of good living, fish being bought in the market, and so regarded as a luxury. porrum et caepe: as examples of frugal fare, cf. herbis et urtica, vs. 7, 8. trucidas: a jocose use of an inappropriate word.
22. utere, etc.: i.e. whichever course of life you take, either of enjoying the good things, or of suppressing the desire for them like a philosopher, don't forget to cultivate my friend Grosphus, etc. Grospho: a friend of the poet having estates in Sicily. Cf. Od. II.16. petet: Iccius would probably have favors to grant as manager of the estates of Agrippa. The two estates were probably contiguous. ultro, freely, i.e. go beyond his request.
23. verum: cf. Sat. II.3.312, note.
24. vilis: i.e. only costing the outlay of a small favor. amicorum: objective genitive. annona, the price, properly the year's crop. Here the idea is that friends are to be bought at a cheap rate when good men need anything, --a little with grateful people goes a long way. Cf. nun dià tà prágmata euonotátous ésti phílous agathoùs ktásasthai, Xen. Mem. II.40.4.
25. tamen: i.e. though my letter has been taken up with other matters than news, the usual theme of letters, yet, etc. quo loco: an almost proverbial expression (hence without the in), doubtless derived from military usage. Cf. Virg. Æn. II.322. Romana res, affairs at Rome, but with a different idea underlying it, inasmuch as all the interests and circumstances of the state as a whole are summed up in this one expression.
26. Cantaber, etc.: the Cantabrians were conquered by an expedition under Agrippa, B.C. 20. In the same year the expedition of Tiberius referred to in Ep. I.3, conquered and caused the death of Artaxias, who was hostile to the Romans, and set Tigranes on the throne of Armenia. Cf. Tac. Ann. II.3.
27. Phraates: in the same year, B.C. 20, the king of the Parthians, apparently alarmed by the progress of the Roman arms, sought peace of the Romans and restored the standards taken in the great defeats of Crassus and Antonius (B.C. 53 and 36).
28. genibus minor, suppliant on his knees; the construction is that of the degree of difference. aurea, etc.: merely telling of a bountiful harvest.

Go to Horace Page
[Horace Page]
Go to Trans. Commentary #11
[Commentary #11]
Go to top of page
[Top of Page]
Go to Trans. Commentary #13
[Commentary #13]
Go to Latin Text
[Latin Text]